4
pillars of medical ethics
5
steps to structure any ethics answer
12
worked scenarios in this guide
The four pillars of medical ethics
| Principle | Meaning | Interview phrase |
|---|---|---|
| Autonomy | Respecting a competent patient's right to make their own decisions | 'The patient has the right to decide, provided they have capacity…' |
| Beneficence | Acting in the patient's best interests | 'We want to do what genuinely benefits the patient…' |
| Non-maleficence | Avoiding harm, or harm that outweighs benefit | 'We must weigh the risk of harm…' |
| Justice | Fairness to everyone, including how resources are shared | 'We also have to think about fairness to other patients…' |
The legal ideas you need
- Consent: valid consent must be informed, voluntary and given by someone with capacity.
- Capacity: under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, a person can make a decision if they can understand, retain and weigh the information and communicate their choice. Capacity is decision-specific and assumed unless shown otherwise.
- Gillick competence: a young person under 16 can consent to treatment if they have enough understanding and maturity to grasp what is involved.
- Fraser guidelines: the specific criteria for giving contraceptive advice to under-16s without parental involvement.
- Confidentiality: the default is to keep patient information private. It can be broken in limited situations, such as a serious risk of harm to others.
- Duty of candour: being open and honest with patients when something goes wrong.
A five-step structure for any ethics station
- 1Summarise the scenario and say you would want more information.
- 2Name the ethical principles in tension.
- 3Consider each stakeholder: the patient, family, staff and wider society.
- 4Bring in any relevant law or professional guidance.
- 5Reach a clear, balanced conclusion, and say how you would support everyone involved.

12 worked medical ethics scenarios
1. The Jehovah's Witness refusing blood
A competent adult can refuse treatment, even life-saving treatment. Explore their understanding, check capacity, discuss alternatives such as bloodless techniques, and respect their decision if they have capacity. Autonomy outweighs beneficence for a competent adult.
2. A 15-year-old asking for contraception
Assess Gillick competence and apply the Fraser guidelines. Encourage them to involve a parent, but if they are competent and the criteria are met, you can provide care confidentially. Consider safeguarding throughout.
3. Telling a patient's family against their wishes
Confidentiality belongs to the patient. Explore why they do not want the family to know, offer support, and respect their wishes unless there is a serious risk to others.
4. A colleague who smells of alcohol
Patient safety comes first. Speak to the colleague privately if it is safe, but escalate to a senior, because patients could be at risk. Show compassion: they may need help.
5. Opt-out organ donation
Weigh increased donor numbers (beneficence and justice) against concerns about presumed consent (autonomy). Mention that families are still consulted, and that public awareness matters.
6. Funding lifestyle-related illness
Discuss justice and the NHS's founding principle of care based on need. Consider that lifestyle is shaped by social factors, the difficulty of drawing lines, and the role of prevention.
7. Assisted dying
Present both sides: autonomy and relief of suffering against protecting vulnerable people and the doctor's role. Acknowledge it is a live debate in UK law and avoid giving a one-sided personal view.
8. A patient asks you to lie to their insurer
Honesty and probity are non-negotiable. Decline politely, explain why, and help the patient with what you can legitimately do.
9. Allocating the last ICU bed
Use clinical need and likelihood of benefit, not social worth. Involve senior colleagues and established criteria, and treat both patients and families with respect.
10. A friend cheating in an exam
Probity matters because future doctors must be trustworthy. Speak to your friend first and encourage them to come forward, and be prepared to report it if it continues.
11. A patient who wants antibiotics for a virus
Explain why antibiotics would not help and the risk of antimicrobial resistance, explore their concerns, and agree a plan, including when to come back.
12. You make a mistake on placement
Duty of candour: tell your supervisor straight away, make sure the patient is safe, be honest with the patient, and reflect on what you would do differently.
Frequently asked questions
What are the four pillars of medical ethics?
Autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice.
What is Gillick competence?
The idea that a young person under 16 can consent to their own treatment if they have enough understanding and maturity to grasp what is involved.
How do I answer an ethics question in a medicine interview?
Summarise the scenario, name the principles in tension, consider every stakeholder, bring in relevant law or guidance, and reach a balanced, clear conclusion.
Do I need to know the law for a medicine interview?
You need the basics: consent, capacity under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, confidentiality, Gillick competence and the Fraser guidelines. Detailed case law is not expected.




